Imported Turf

While traditional media outlets claim to “embrace the conversation,” are they still holding it at arm’s length? Is it enough to host comments and invite input online, without the due diligence to see if others are manipulating the agenda?

A few days ago, I wrote about what appeared to be a fairly obvious case of Astroturfing – the practice of creating fake “grass roots” in order to make it seem like public opinion was different than reality. One of my biggest clues was the sheer volume of comments posted between the moment the story went live at 5 a.m., and the time I read them (dozens of them) at 6:15 a.m.

If newspapers were a little more sophisticated about this sort of thing, they might check their IP logs and see the source of all that recent traffic — most of which is not washed through any proxy, and does give decent geographic information.

For example, let me show you the sort of data one can mine if they use the right tools:

The two images you see to the right are screen captures from my Sitemeter administration page. They show two separate visits to Occam’s RazR, both time and date stamped.

As you can see, both of these visits came from Boca Raton, Florida, and the visits overlap in time. Curiously, you can see from the out-click information that both of them left comments. They also come from different browsers, which is a nifty little way to be logged onto the same site concurrently from different profiles.

As it happens, those comments correlate in time to a pair of comments left here, by people purporting to be “5 Points Joe” and “Garlic Rolls,” two screen names you see used in the AL.com comment threads about Bingo. “Garlic Rolls” is one of the many commenters who is firmly for a vote of the people and is pro-gambling, while “5 Points Joe” is a little more skeptical, and is often accused of being a “Sock Puppet” handle for Pulitzer Prize-winning editorial page editor Joey Kennedy. (That accusation is laughable on several counts, but I digress.)

Here is the screen shot of my WordPress comment administration panel, verifying the IP addresses of the comments. I took the liberty of blurring out the email addresses used by those who posted, for reasons I will get to later.

Since the panel shows newest comments at the top, you can see that the “5 Points Joe” comment, left at 6:27pm, came first. I seriously doubt this is from the real 5PointsJoe, because a quick look at his comment history shows him engaged on a number of issues not related to gambling in Alabama. Why would a paid lobbyist based in Boca Raton be so involved in flood warnings at schools, police trials, and whether George Barber is a good guy for offering free land downtown for business development.

Brad (claiming to be Garlic Rolls), on the other hand, has only posted in bingo-related threads. And in the comment, Garlic claims to be on unemployment in the state of Alabama, while posting from Boca Raton. I would think that someone whose lamenting the loss of his/her minimum wage job would be staying someplace cheaper than Boca Raton while cashing those Alabama state unemployment checks.

But hey, I’ve been wrong before.

I’m not a betting man, but here’s where I would put the smart money:

  • Both comments were left by the same person.
  • Neither email address shows up in searches.
  • Wanting to throw me off the trail, the Phony Joe was left first, so the Garlic Rolls could respond.

The entire thing reeks of underhanded manipulation. And it parallels a more fundamental question raised by the real Joey Kennedy of the Birmingham News, about transparency and our right to know who is paying for all the issue advertising.

Round-Up the Turf Merchants

If I were a reporter, I’d be wanting to chase down some pertinent data. A couple of years ago, this same newspaper won a Pulitzer Prize for investigating corruption in Alabama’s two-year college system, and that entire series of stories started with a request for a raw data dump. Brett Blackledge asked for the raw records, and started stitching together the tendrils until the narrative came into focus. But I’m not so certain that will be as easy to accomplish here, because most newspaper web sites are run as completely different divisions. I do know that AL.com is run out-of-state, and there is likely not decent access to the raw information that could establish patterns of astroturfing.

What about privacy? The News doesn’t publish letters sent anonymously, so I don’t buy the precedent that this is somehow invasive.

I love my lawn. It is good turf. But some turf is wrong, and deserves to be terminated.

So, who wants to do a little digging into firms that handle political campaigns and public relations efforts out of Boca Raton?

Share Button

Under the Hood

There’s a bit of a funny meme passing around right now, and it has to do with a position taken by the Ku Klux Klan of Arkansas, in this screenshot:

The “joke” here is that members of the Westboro Baptist Church have been so vile, that the Klan is even disavowing them.

Lost in all of the irony about Hate Groups and Unpopular Protests are the three letters I omitted above: LLC.

Limited Liability Corporation.

Is this a case of the Klan trying to appear legitimate? (That’s the answer you get from their site, which I will not link to.)

If and when choose to go to court, we stand on an equal footing with our detractors, we cannot be dismissed for lack of legal standing or credibility. This is the type of thinking our detractors have feared the most! The Ku Klux Klan, LLC. is leading the way with bold innovative thinking all the while respecting the beauty and purpose of Klankraft and building on the legacy left us by all those who have gone before, remaining a positive force for good! Yes it does cost more and take more time to do things right the first time, but as the work is done it is a lasting work that will stand the test.

Likely, that air of legitimacy is not the motivation.

It is more likely an unintended consequence of the way in which the Klan was systematically taken down by the Southern Poverty Law Center. The SPLC simply took the Klan leaders to court, and sued them into oblivion.

The LLC (Limited Liability Corporation) is thus a financial move, to allow Klansmen to avoid future civil damages that would bankrupt them.

I’m willing to bet that Morris Dees and his legal team are none too pleased to see various Klan organizations resurfacing, and using what amounts to a financial dodge as a way to tout their legitimacy and enhance their messaging.

History is more fun to study through the lens of Unintended Consequences.

Share Button

Journalistic Sodbusting

Astroturfing” refers to any shady public relations practice where one manufactures the appearance of “grass roots” support. I had never heard of the word until transitioning from news to public affairs (a mere six years, two months and twenty-two days ago, but who is counting?)

Journalists, by nature, are fairly good at playing the skeptic; and very cranky when they get played. When part of the story centers on public sentiment – like the case study I present to you now – they may get more than irate; they might just get even.

Particulars in a moment, but first the mother of all disclaimers:

The following post references events and issues of a political nature in the state of Alabama, and unlike most of what I write here is of a very time-sensitive nature.

This post is the work of me and me alone.

Because anything that is even remotely political ends up being blamed or framed on my employer (whether warranted or not,) let me state unequivocally that my employer, supervisor, nor anyone in my company knows I am writing this, nor am I under any directive, suggestion or hint that it would be worthwhile.

For the record, I have not taken a public position on the issues of gambling/gaming/bingo in the state of Alabama, and don’t care enough to research them.

Nobody has paid me for this post. I don’t even run ads on the site.

But I am interested in the process of communications, and how organizations attempt to persuade.

Are you hooked yet? Here we go…

[Read more…]

Share Button

The Future of Journalism, Part Two

(The following was posted last week at Media Bullseye – and is republished here to add context. Discussion about this piece at “The El Show,” at BlogTalkRadio. Skip to the update if you’d like.)

Dear Journalist:

I know you’ve been dying to grab that bite of lunch I offered, but I know how it is these days. The calendar is a blur, the endless rush from event to interview to photo opportunity, then back to the newsroom for the daily ritual of wordsmithery and crash story-telling. I remember those days, when a lunch seated somewhere other than a drive-through and a bucket seat was a treat. [Read more…]

Share Button

I was suppose to be an anchor

…but they gave it to a minority.

(More from the mcarp archives… the prophetic genius and brilliance are his;
the ones/zeros, pixels, pictures and subheads and pull-quotes are mine.)

…and good-looking white kids are having to do without.

There are no white people left anchoring TV news anymore.

To be honest, I haven’t checked every TV station in America to confirm it, but I’m sure it’s true. Because every time I turn around, I hear some white person griping that they were ‘cheated’ out of some glamorous, overpaid, underworked anchor job because the station ‘had to get a minority.’

This has happened so often that I have to assume that every on-air job in the industry has now been handed to non-white talent.

The complaint, posted to some Internet chat board, usually looks something like this:

my agent says I was suppose to get a anchor job in a top ten... but they had to give it to a minority... I'm really tired of this... I've been here eieghteen months, and I hate reporting... I should be anchoring right now... it's not fair... they shouldnt hire anchors because of race...

No, they should hire anchors for some higher quality.

Like looks, for example.

Personally, I’m of the opinion that no one is ‘suppose’ to be an anchor. That’s like saying you’re ‘suppose’ to win the lottery. Or that you’re ‘suppose’ to find a bag with a million dollars in it lying on the street.

And strangely enough, you never hear someone complain a minority ‘stole’ a photographer’s job, or a producer’s job. It’s always the cush anchor jobs that are being unfairly handed out to blacks, Hispanics, and Asians when there are so many stunning, beautiful white people doing without.

Being a news anchor is a lot like being one of The Backstreet Boys, anyway. You look great, get a lot of money for displaying a modicum of talent, and everyone else looks at you and wonders why it’s happening.

The rest of us, black and white alike, just have to go on working for a living.

(originally published by Michael Carpenter, republished with permission.)

Share Button

The Last Business Book You’ll Ever Need

A friend of mine was lamenting that he wanted to write another business book, but couldn’t think of anything new to say.

So I beat him to the punch.

Major Publishing Announcement

Sometime soon, Ike Pigott will release “The Last Business Book You Will Ever Need – a Primer for Self-reliance in the Digital Age of Digitalness.”

Chapter 1: GO READ THE *OLD* STUFF ON YOUR SHELF! There are insights there you missed when you were skimming, trying to impress people.

Chapter 2: GO TO THE ——- LIBRARY! There are pretty good books there, too.

Chapter 3: GO OUTSIDE AND GET SOME FRESH AIR, YOU PASTY LUMP OF GOO! Books? Really? You think the answers are in BOOKS?

Chapter 4: SUBSCRIBE TO MY NEWSLETTER. It’s only $25 a year, and you can pony that up, since you’re not buying any more books.

The cover needs a little work, but we can outsource that. I think I read about that somewhere…

Share Button

Political Geometry

{{myquote|Modern politics has become an exercise in bending over backwards to bend your opponent forwards.}}

Share Button